Improving regulation of the use of soils and subsoils dumps in the Russian Federation
https://doi.org/10.19047/0136-1694-2024-121-6-27
Abstract
The analysis of the practice for regulating the use of dumps of soils and subsoils in the Russian Federation is carried out. It is shown that the existing regulations do not meet modern requirements for the protection and rational use of dumps of soils and subsoils. The absence of a unified recycling approach has been revealed. In some regulatory documents, dumps of soils and subsoils are considered as material for the reclamation of disturbed lands, in others – as industrial waste. Disagreement with the practice of classifying all dumps of soils and subsoils as waste of hazard classes 3–5 and subject to export to special polygons is justified. Disposal of such waste materials is administratively or criminally punishable. This approach to the material of soil excavation causes great harm to both the economy and the environment as a whole. It is proposed to change the practice of irrational use of soil and subsoil dump material and make appropriate changes to regulatory documents. One of such changes may be the introduction of the gradation “environmentally safe waste” into the documents on the definition of the hazard class of waste, with the prescription for the use of soil and subsoil dumps belonging to this category without restrictions on use in the national economy. It is proposed to clarify the magnitude of the soil thickness (soil layer) of 5 m, including the maximum depth of occurrence of fertile soil layer and potentially fertile layer. This value corresponds to the accepted stratigraphic rule on the general regularity of the structure of the sedimentary shell of the Earth. According to this point of view, soils are underlain by subsurface geological rocks, which does not imply the presence of intermediate geological layers between soils and subsurface.
About the Authors
A. L. IvanovRussian Federation
7 Bld. 2 Pyzhevskiy per., Moscow 119017
V. S. Stolbovoy
Russian Federation
7 Bld. 2 Pyzhevskiy per., Moscow 119017
L. S. Bakumenko
Russian Federation
7 Bld. 2 Pyzhevskiy per., Moscow 119017
A. M. Grebennikov
Russian Federation
7 Bld. 2 Pyzhevskiy per., Moscow 119017
References
1. Bogatyrev I.R., Uchastok nedr kak samostojatel'nyj ob#ekt grazhdanskih prav (Subsoil plot as an independent object of civil rights), Molodoj uchenyj, 2018, No. 44(230), pp. 110–112.
2. VSN 014-89, Construction of trunk and field pipelines. Environmental protection. Minneftegazstroy, Мoscow, 1990, 46 p.
3. State standard, GOST R 59057-2020, Environmental protection. Lands. General requirements for reclamation of disturbed lands.
4. State standard, GOST P 58486-2019, Environmental protection. Soils. Nomenclature of indicators of sanitary condition.
5. State standard, GOST 17.5.1.03-86, Nature protection. Earths. Classification of overburden and host rocks for biological recultivation of lands.
6. State standard, GOST P 57447-2017, Best available technologies. Recultivation of lands and land plots contaminated with oil and oil products. Basic provisions.
7. State standard, GOST P 59060-2020, Environmental protection. Lands. Classification of disturbed lands for reclamation purposes.
8. State standard, GOST 17.5.3.05-84. Nature protection. Recultivation of lands. General requirements for land reclamation.
9. State standard, GOST 17.4.3.02-85. Nature protection. Soils. Requirements for the protection of the fertile soil layer during earthworks.
10. State standard, GOST 17.5.3.06-85. Nature protection. Earths. Requirements for determining the norms of removal of the fertile soil layer in the course of excavation works.
11. State (national) report on the state and use of land in the Russian Federation in 2022 (official website of the Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography, section ‘State (national) report on the state and use of land’, November 2023), URL: http://www.rosreestr.gov.ru.
12. Derbentseva A.M., Krupskaya L.T., Stepanova A.I., Rekul'tivacija degradirovannyh i vosstanovlenie razrushennyh pochv (Recultivation of degraded and restoration of destroyed soils), Vladivostok: DVGU. 2006, 70 p.
13. Unified State Register of Soil Resources of Russia. Version 1.0. Collective monograph, Moscow: V.V. Dokuchaev Soil Science Institute, RAS, 2014, 768 p.
14. Law of the Russian Federation N 2395-I “On Subsoil” dated 21.02.92 (as amended on 25.12.2023 – came into force from 01.03.2024).
15. Land Code of the Russian Federation of 25.10.2001 N 136-FZ (ed. of 04.08.2023) (with amendments and additions, in force from 15.08.2023).
16. Mashtakov K.M., Uchastki nedr kak ob’ekty grazhdanskih (Subsoil plots as objects of civil rights), Jurist-pravoved, 2018, No. 1, pp. 147–151.
17. Methodological recommendations for the reclamation of land disturbed during transport construction, Мoscow, 1983, 17 p.
18. Motorina L.V., Ovchinnikov V.A., Promyshlennost' i rekul'tivacija zemel' (Industry and land reclamation), Moscow: Mysl, 1975, 240 p.
19. Bedritsky A.I. (Ed.), National report “Global climate and soil cover of Russia: assessment of risks and ecological and economic consequences of land degradation, adaptive systems and technologies of rational nature management (agriculture and forestry)”, Moscow: V.V. Dokuchaev Soil Science Institute, GEOS, 2018, 286 p.
20. Perchik A.I., Gornoe pravo (Mining Law), Moscow: Izdatel'skij Dom “Filologija tri”, 2002, 525 p.
21. Resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation dated 10 July 2018 N 800 “On the reclamation and conservation of land” (as amended and supplemented).
22. Resolution of the Government of the Russian Federation “On the composition of sections of project documentation and requirements for their content” dated 16.02.2008, No. 87.
23. Order of the Ministry of Natural Resources of the Russian Federation dated 04.12.2014 N 536 “On Approval of criteria for attributing wastes to 1–5 hazard classes by the degree of negative impact on the environment”.
24. RD 39-00147105-006-97, Instruction on recultivation of the lands disturbed and polluted during emergency and overhaul of main oil pipelines, Mosccow: Transneft, 1997, 24 p.
25. RD 34.02.202-95, Recommendations on reclamation of spent ash and slag dumps of thermal power plants, Мoscow: 1995, 9 p.
26. RP.1.279-2-89, Methodical design guide “Recultivation of lands disturbed during construction of communication facilities”, Мoscow: 1989, 13 p.
27. Smetanin V.I., Rekul'tivacija i obustrojstvo narushennyh zemel' (Recultivation and arrangement of disturbed lands), Moscow: Kolos, 2000, 96 p.
28. Federal Law from 18.06.2001 N 78-FZ (ed. from 30.12.2021) “On land management”.
29. Federal Law of 10.01.2002 N 7-FZ (ed. of 25.12.2023) “On Environmental Protection” (with amendments and additions, in force since 01.07.2024).
30. Federal Law “On Production and Consumption Waste” dated 24.06.1998 N 89-FZ.
31. Federal classification catalogue of wastes. Order of Rosprirodnadzor dated 22.05.2017 No. 242 (ed. 02.11.2018) “On Approval of the Federal classification catalogue of wastes” (with amendments and additions, effective from 04.10.2021).
32. European Commission. In depth report: soil sealing. 2012.
33. Pistocchi A. et al., Soil sealing and flood risks in the plains of EmiliaRomagna. Italy. 2015.
34. Soil Strategy for 2030. Reaping the benefits of healthy soils for people, food, nature and climate SWD (2021) 323 final. New EU Soil Strategy for 2030, URL: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/publications/eu-soil-strategy2030_en.
Review
For citations:
Ivanov A.L., Stolbovoy V.S., Bakumenko L.S., Grebennikov A.M. Improving regulation of the use of soils and subsoils dumps in the Russian Federation. Dokuchaev Soil Bulletin. 2024;(121):6-27. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.19047/0136-1694-2024-121-6-27